The Debate Rating

An Elo for arguing.

1500
everyone starts here
Provisional

One number that follows you from round to round, like a chess rating. It moves when you win or lose against real people, and only then. The judge writes your ballot; the people you beat write your rating.

The ladder

Titan Elite Varsity Contender Regular Rookie Newcomer 1900+ 1750 1650 1550 1450 1300 you 1500

Six tiers. Everyone starts at 1500, between Regular and Contender. The top of the ladder is earned against people, never against the AI.

What moves it

You 1500 beat 1700 +24 big jump You 1500 beat 1500 +14 You 1500 beat 1300 +6 You 1500 lost to 1700 −5 losing up barely dents you Speaker points never rank you. Only results against people do.

Beating a stronger opponent moves you more. Practice rounds against the AI sharpen you without touching the number.

The number comes with honesty built in

round 1 round 5 round 10 wide range: the system admits it does not know you yet settled: now it ranks

Plain Elo would move you 30 points on a coin flip and call it skill. The Debate Rating is Glicko-2: it carries a confidence range that narrows as you play and widens if you vanish for months. Until 3 rated rounds settle it, your rating is provisional: it shows on your profile and drives matchmaking but holds no numbered place on the public board.

Debated before? Skip the blank 1500.

12001400 16001800 blank start · 1500 seeded from your record · ~1720

Look yourself up and claim your record: the index covers hundreds of tournaments of published Tabroom results, and your rating seeds from your real wins, losses, and elim runs. Wide range on purpose, once ever, and only before your first rated round, so nobody re-rolls a bad start.

Claim your record Find a rated round Practice against the AI

Questions

Is the Debate Rating the same as chess Elo?

Same idea, different math. Elo assumes you play often enough for noise to average out. Debate rounds are sparser, so Debatable uses Glicko-2, which tracks a rating and how certain the system is about it. A new account and a proven account can both sit at 1500 and mean very different things.

What moves the rating?

Winning and losing rated rounds against real people. Beating a stronger opponent moves it more than beating a weaker one. The AI judge's speaker points never rank you; only results against people do.

Can I start with a rating that matches my experience?

Yes. If you have competed before, you can look up your published Tabroom results and seed your rating from your actual record. The seed carries wide uncertainty and tightens as you debate.

Why is my rating marked provisional?

A rating stays provisional until the system is confident: you need at least 3 rated rounds and enough results for the uncertainty to narrow. Provisional ratings display and matchmake but do not hold a numbered place on the public board.

What are the tiers?

Newcomer, Rookie from 1300, Regular from 1450, Contender from 1550, Varsity from 1650, Elite from 1750, and Titan from 1900. Everyone starts at 1500 with high uncertainty.

The rating runs server-side and every change is recorded with a before and after, so a rating can always explain itself.